Stock Went Up But You Lost Money?
Finally Understand Why - And How to Fix It
You're not bad at trading - you're missing the data pros use. See IV crush risk, theta decay, implied move, and probability of profit before you trade.
The Problem Every Beginner Faces
Real trader frustrations from Reddit (with actual upvotes)
I bought a call betting the stock would go up and it did but I still lost money
If you don't understand what this stuff means you need to do some more research into how options work. There's a lot more that goes into the pricing of options than just the underlying stock price.
How did I make profit? TSLA was at $226 but my $215 put made 75%?
You don't need TSLA to be at $215 to make money off that contract, you just need it to go down from whatever price TSLA was at when you bought the PUT. Investopedia is your friend for learning the GREEKS, which DELTA will be your primary answer.
1st time options buyer. Need your advice please.
I bought 1 GLD contract in June and then in September I thought I was pretty smart so I bought 2 more. First - the options were more for fun and to learn with. I'm willing to lose it all but hoping to understand what happened.
Why most people lose money on options
Most people lose money on calls because they treat them like stocks. With stocks you just need to be directionally right eventually. With calls you must be right on direction, magnitude, AND timing simultaneously. Add in theta decay bleeding you daily, IV crush...
You're not bad at trading. You're just missing the data that professionals use.
Market makers see gamma walls, implied moves, and max pain levels. You see... the stock price.
See What the Pros See
Before you place a trade, see the data that actually matters
Feature 1: Pre-Trade Checker
Key Gamma Levels
VALUE score: 52/100 (medium - not cheap). SENTIMENT: Max pain at $180 suggests dealers want it lower. TIMING: Watch the $190 resistance level. Consider taking profits early or using a debit spread to reduce cost.
AIME has analyzed this for youNVDA
Bottom-line
NVDA jumped $6.59, but Sarah's call lost $230 because the 'excitement premium' dropped faster than the stock rose. Try debit spreads instead - they cost 67% less and ignore the hype swings.
1.Value Pillar: Is This Option Too Expensive?
Before entering this trade, our Value metrics would have warned you:
2.Timing Pillar: Why Your Option Lost Money Even Though Stock Went Up
Stock went up 3.7%, but your option lost value because of two timing killers:
3.Sentiment Pillar: What the Smart Money Saw
Looking at put/call ratios and open interest, institutions were positioned differently than you:
AIME analyzes gamma levels, IV rank, and market catalysts to give you personalized insights
Feature 2: "Why Am I Losing?" Diagnostic
Stock up from $174 to $180.93 but I'm down $230?
The "excitement premium" (IV) you paid was too high. Think of it like buying concert tickets - you bought at peak hype ($850 total), then interest dropped 27% overnight to $620. Our Value pillar tracks IV Rank to warn you when you're overpaying.
Your option loses $45 per day just from time passing - that's 5.3% of the option value per day. Our Timing pillar shows you theta decay percentage so you know how fast your option melts like ice cream.
Max Pain at $180 means dealers want NVDA below your $185 strike. You were swimming upstream. Our Sentiment pillar tracks where institutional money is positioned so you can trade with them, not against them.
Use a $180/$190 debit spread instead. Costs $280 vs $850 (67% cheaper - Value win), eliminates IV crush risk (Timing win), and aligns with dealer positioning (Sentiment win). You'd be up $135 (+48%) right now instead of down $230 (-27%).
Your TIMING (theta decay) and VALUE (IV crush) scores were both red flags. The stock direction was right, but those two pillars were working against you. Next time, check all 5 pillars before entering.
Feature 3: Earnings IV Crush Calculator
VALUE Pillar Alert: NVDA options historically lose 58% of their value within 24 hours after earnings due to IV crush. That's the "excitement premium" evaporating.
TIMING Pillar Alert: The closer you get to earnings, the more IV gets pumped up. A $500 call bought before earnings would be worth only $210 the next day, even if NVDA stock went up 2%.
Strategy Tip (All 5 Pillars): Our scoring system will flag "Days to Earnings < 7" as red in the TIMING pillar. Wait until after earnings when VALUE improves (IV drops), or sell premium instead of buying it.
VALUE Pillar Warning: IV is 45% above normal - you're overpaying for the 'excitement premium'. TIMING Pillar: Post-earnings, this will drop 30-40% (IV crush). Even if stock goes your way, your option loses value.
Feature 4: Daily Catalyst Calendar
Upcoming Market-Moving Events
Bad Timing Warning: With CPI today and FOMC tomorrow, the TIMING pillar score is very low. The "excitement premium" (IV) will spike before these events, then crash right after. Don't buy calls/puts right now.
VALUE Impact: High IV before events means options are expensive (low VALUE score). After the event, IV crashes and VALUE improves - but if you bought before, you lose money even if you're right on direction.
Strategy (Using TIMING + VALUE Together): Wait until after FOMC when TIMING improves and VALUE gets better (cheaper options). Or, if you're advanced, sell premium to profit from the IV crush instead of being a victim of it.
TIMING Pillar Alert: 3 major events this week will cause IV to spike then crash. Your timing score is LOW. Wait until after Wednesday when VALUE improves (cheaper options) and TIMING is better.
AIME's Complete Analysis: All 4 Features Working Together
VALUE Pillar (Is it cheap?): IV Rank was 52% - not terrible, but you weren't getting a bargain. The option had an elevated "excitement premium" baked in. After you bought, IV dropped 27% (IV crush). This is why our VALUE metrics check IV Rank, IV Percentile, and IV/HV Ratio.
SENTIMENT Pillar (Clear signal?): Put/call ratios and open interest showed Max Pain at $180 - dealers wanted NVDA below your $185 strike. You were betting against the house. Our SENTIMENT metrics measure signal clarity - high score = clear directional conviction you can trust.
TIMING Pillar (When to enter?): Your option was losing $45/day in theta decay (5.3% per day). Plus, with earnings in 76 days and FOMC this week, timing was poor. Our TIMING pillar calculates theta decay %, days to earnings, and event risk to help you avoid these killers.
ACTIVITY + LIQUIDITY Pillars: These would have shown if there was unusual volume (ACTIVITY) and if you could execute at fair prices (LIQUIDITY). Both were fine for NVDA, but VALUE, SENTIMENT, and TIMING were all warning signs.
Bottom Line: If even 2-3 pillars show red flags, don't trade. All 5 pillars working together would have saved you $230 and shown you a better strategy (debit spreads cost 67% less, eliminate IV risk). This is what pros see - now you can too.
Instead of guessing, you'll know before you trade
Built for Beginners
Everything you need to stop losing on options trades
Learn how we score options opportunitiesKnow If You're Overpaying
See IV Rank and IV Percentile to know if the 'excitement premium' is too high. Our Value pillar tells you if options are cheap (good for buyers) or expensive (good for sellers).
See Where Smart Money Is Betting
Check put/call ratios and open interest skew to understand where institutions are positioned. Our Sentiment pillar shows you which direction the flow is pointing.
Spot Unusual Activity
Track volume surges and unusual options activity to catch big moves early. Our Activity pillar detects when something interesting is happening.
Trade Without Slippage
See bid-ask spreads and volume depth before you trade. Our Liquidity pillar ensures you can get in and out at fair prices.
Enter At The Right Time
Know theta decay %, days to earnings, and event risk. Our Timing pillar shows you when to enter - avoiding IV crush and time decay killers.
How It Works
Three steps to better options trading
Enter Your Ticker
Type any stock symbol - SPY, NVDA, TSLA, AAPL, anything
See Key Levels
Implied move, gamma walls, max pain, IV rank - all in one view
Trade Smarter
Plain English explanations tell you exactly what the data means
Setup time
During beta
No commitment
Our Options Opportunity Score
Every insight is powered by our comprehensive scoring system
See it in actionValue
Is it cheap?
- IV Rank - How expensive is the "excitement premium"?
- IV Percentile - Is volatility high or low right now?
- IV/HV Ratio - Are you overpaying for hype?
Sentiment
Clear sentiment signal?
- Put/Call Ratio - How clear is the directional conviction?
- OI Skew - Strong positioning = clear signal
- Flow Direction - Is smart money bullish or bearish?
Activity
How active?
- Volume Surge - Is trading volume unusually high today?
- Unusual Activity - Are big players making moves?
- OI Changes - Is interest building or fading?
Liquidity
Can I trade?
- Bid-Ask Spread - How much does it cost to enter/exit?
- Volume Depth - Can you get filled at fair prices?
- Open Interest - Are there enough contracts to trade?
Timing
When to enter?
- Theta Decay - How fast is your option melting?
- Days to Earnings - Will IV crush kill your trade?
- Event Risk - What catalysts are coming up?
Combined
The complete picture
- All 5 pillars working together
- Comprehensive opportunity scoring
- Data-driven confidence
AIME Analyzes All 5 Pillars Instantly
Our AI doesn't just show you data - it combines all 5 pillars to give you clear, actionable insights in plain English. Every recommendation is backed by comprehensive scoring across Value, Sentiment, Activity, Liquidity, and Timing.
Explore the scoring systemYou're Not Alone
Thousands of traders are confused by the same things
Can someone explain how I'm still losing money on this put option even when the stock dropped?
The stock went down like I predicted but my put is still red. I thought puts make money when stocks go down? What am I missing here?
$88k realized profit off TSLA IV crush in 24 hours
The IV for TSLA went through the roof over the past week. The premiums were too juicy to ignore. So, I sold 200 contracts. Well, 24 hours later, TSLA went down a little and the IV crushed. This is how you profit from understanding volatility.
I'd be rich if I weren't so scared. I'm really good at watching money go up.
I keep entering positions, seeing them go green, then watching the gains disappear because I don't know when to exit. Anyone else have this problem?
The answer is always the same: you're missing critical data
Theta decay, IV crush, gamma walls - OptionsIQ shows you all of it
Ready to Stop Trading Blind?
Join the waitlist and get free access when we launch